Quote Originally Posted by PAllen View Post
How does showing that playoff teams from conference A are clearly better than last place teams from conference B show that conference A is better than conference B? I would say that this year the PL was comparable to the CAA. That said, this was a terrible year for the PL, so that's quite a surprise. In years to come, the PL might surpass the CAA, but I doubt it. All the more reason why you should judge teams by what they do on the field in any given year, not what they or their conference mates have done in previous years.
I think that was my point. He was saying that the PL was better than the CAA simply because Colgate beat UNH and JMU. Well that is the same as just comparing the top teams in two conferences. Say JSU were to beat NDSU does that make the OVC better than the MVFC? Or does that just mean that JSU was better than NDSU?