Who should be added to the Payton Award list?

[UNH72Plus]

After 5 weeks who has performed well enough to be added to the Payton Award list? Here's some suggestions -

1. Kevin Decker from UNH is currently #5 on the FCS passing efficiency rating and has rushed for 157 yards and 5 TD's.
2. Forcier from Furman has a pass efficiency rating of 234.37.
3. Lum of Lehigh has thrown for 1809 yards.
4. Rumble of Idaho State leads the FCS with 757 receiving yards and should be added just for name alone.
5. McCaffery from Portland State is averaging 169.67 yards rushing per game through three games.
6. Bell of Indiana State is averaging 153.4 ypg rushing through five games.

While we're at it, who should be dropped from the list?

[blackfordpu]

Who is on it now?

[TheRevSFA]

If Flanders from SH State isn't on it, then he should be.

[Reign of Terrier]

definitely Forcier, I'd add Alvin Sceaneax (if I could spell it right) of Wofford on the Buchanan list as well

[UNH72Plus]

Go to sportsnetwork.com for the complete list.

[ValleyChamp]

Tirrell Rennie, UNI QB.

683 Passing yards, 4 TDS 0 INT
400 Rushing yards 5 TDS

[PaladinFan]

Jerodis Williams of Furman.

For whatever reason, no one mentions him, but he's leading the SoCon in rushing before putting up 175 on WCU.

[UNIFanSince1983]

Tirrell Rennie, UNI QB.

683 Passing yards, 4 TDS 0 INT
400 Rushing yards 5 TDS

Pretty sure Rennie was already on the Watch List.

http://www.sportsnetwork.com/merge/tsnform.aspx?c=sportsnetwork&page=cfoot2/fcsawards/index.aspx

Sure enough he was.

[frozennorth]

Williams, soph corner ndsu

Miller, rb und.

[Twentysix]

Wow how is marcus williams not on the buchanan list?

MWILL sophomore Cornerback

7 solo tackles 8 assists 15 total.

2 INT. 5 pbu. 12 points scored.

Obviously we know...

http://www.gobison.com/pics32/640/TF/TFGCHAQELDLKYWA.20110924150947.jpg

[FurmanWins!!]

Chris Forcier and Jerodis Williams please ;) Wow FU has one good looking offense right now, hope it continues, Beat Samford!!!!

[Lehigh Football Nation]

Lum has more passing touchdowns than anyone else in Division I - FCS or FBS. He has to be on the list.

[gofurman]

How could Forcier at Furman not be on the list - I think he leads all divisions of college footbll in passer efficiency rating with 12(?) TDs, no INT, at least one rushing TD.. heck last week alone (yes, vs PC - the same PC that Wofford beat in the last minute) he had 7TD via air and one running ! (National player of the week by at least two services). This week 4 TD passing , no INT... on da road. I think his rating is like 290 now !!! After 5 weeks of play I have NEVER seen that , ever...

Defenses will get better and that rating will certainly fall but at mid-year I think they have to put him on the list

[hidalgo]

Two Players from Duquesne need to be looked at..........QB Sean Patterson has thrown for 1073 yards 13 td 4 int and has rushed for 269 yards with an efficiency rating of 153.51, Running Back Larry McCoy has rushed for 695 yards an average of 139.00 per game for the First Place Dukes in The NEC. Both players are Juniors.

[Keeper]

Lehigh QB Chris Lum xthumbsupx

[beauspencer]

Terriun Crump - Western Illinois (26 catches, 565 yards, 4 TD)

[crusader11]

Lum has more passing touchdowns than anyone else in Division I - FCS or FBS. He has to be on the list.

Yup, I agree. Lehigh has one of the best offenses in the FCS this year. November 5th is shaping up to be a great, great day for college football in the Lehigh Valley. Looks like I should start to look up flights for that one.

[RichH2]

Yup, I agree. Lehigh has one of the best offenses in the FCS this year. November 5th is shaping up to be a great, great day for college football in the Lehigh Valley. Looks like I should start to look up flights for that one.

Look forward to the game also. Lucky for me its only a couple of hour drive. ABE has a pretty decent schedule of flights. About half hour to Goodman. Since neither of us has a great pass defense we should top our scores with UNH

[katstrapper]

If Flanders from SH State isn't on it, then he should be.

Rev,

I think he should at least get a look, but I am undecided if he should be on it or not. His stats are definitely worthy of a look though.....

SHSU... 4-0

Tim Flanders, RB... Soph (National Rankings in NCAA)

9th in rushing ................ 126 ypg
9th in all purpose yds....... 178 ypg
4th in scoring.................. 10.5 ppg

[DJKyR0]

Williams, soph corner ndsu

The Payton Award is for offense only. He should definitely be a name on the Buchanan, though.

Unfortunately, I don't know if DJ McNorton (NDSU RB) has had enough production to warrant continued watch list cred. He's got some TDs and had a good game Saturday but just hasn't been able to do much this season aside from a big run against Minnesota yardage-wise. That said, still seven games left to play so maybe I'm speaking too soon. He's certainly a potent guy on offense.

[TwoFeathers]

Just give it to Lum already??? Completing 65.7 percent of his passes for 1,809 yards and 19 touchdowns so far?

PS, Lum's not on there... but should be.

[TwoFeathers]

How about who to remove... Bo Levi Mitchell and Brandon Kaufman, both of them...

[Bobcat in NC]

And maybe replace one of them with Cody Kirk, RB, Montana State.

89 rushes, 502 yards, 7 TD
10 receptions, 152 yards

Maybe that's just because I'd love to see the Bobcats with 2 SOPHOMORES on the watch list. xbowx

[UNH72Plus]

Sportsnetwork.com says the list will be revised this week.

[Southsider]

Yup, I agree. Lehigh has one of the best offenses in the FCS this year. November 5th is shaping up to be a great, great day for college football in the Lehigh Valley. Looks like I should start to look up flights for that one.

There are ATL to LVIA daily....

[AppAlum2003]

Jeremy Kimbrough - he scores just as many touchdowns as the ASU offense.

[crusader11]

There are ATL to LVIA daily....

Looking into that, as well as flights to Philly. Thanks!

[appfan2008]

Jeremy Kimbrough - he scores just as many touchdowns as the ASU offense.
offense only

[appfan2008]

I will tell you who should NOT be on that list and that is Deandre Pressley

[AppAlum2003]

offense only

Hence, the joke. He's our best offensive player.

[ngineer]

Yup, I agree. Lehigh has one of the best offenses in the FCS this year. November 5th is shaping up to be a great, great day for college football in the Lehigh Valley. Looks like I should start to look up flights for that one.

Not hard. Delta has several flights/day between Atlanta and ABE Airport. Let me know if your going to attend.

[UNH72Plus]

As you may have seen in another thread Decker, Lum, Rumble, & Bell got added to the list.

[Bearkat-Backer]

Rev,

I think he should at least get a look, but I am undecided if he should be on it or not. His stats are definitely worthy of a look though.....

SHSU... 4-0

Tim Flanders, RB... Soph (National Rankings in NCAA)

9th in rushing ................ 126 ypg
9th in all purpose yds....... 178 ypg
4th in scoring.................. 10.5 ppg

If he stays consistent he will start getting more looks as others trail off.

[crusader11]

Not hard. Delta has several flights/day between Atlanta and ABE Airport. Let me know if your going to attend.

Assuming that HC and Lehigh both take care of business in the Patriot League, I'll be traveling up to this one for sure. How's that new casino that opened up recently?

[Southsider]

Assuming that HC and Lehigh both take care of business in the Patriot League, I'll be traveling up to this one for sure. How's that new casino that opened up recently?
Casino doing very well! Now with Table Games. The new Sands Hotel opened over the summer. The smart money that week will be on LU!

[crusader11]

The smart money that week will be on LU!

Not sure if Holy Cross will be able to win AND cover the points they're giving, so you may be right. xrolleyesx

[Wildcat80]

Kevin Decker of New Hampshire was very deservedly added!!!!!!