The Official: You're In / You're out thread!

[Retro]

I started this thread to post teams that lock themselves in or eliminate themselves from the playoffs based on today's results or already have wrapped up the AQ...

AQ or likely At Large....

POST TEAMS as they occur.....

IN:

James Madison - AQ
Appalachian State - AQ
Weber State - AQ
South Carolina State - AQ

[CharlestonAppFan]

Looks like Maine is out now

[R3TRO]

UNH at 9-2, likely in.

[ccd494]

Looks like Maine is out now

Which sucks. There are not 16 better teams than Maine in the nation. Don't worry though. I'm sure that 60-10 App win over an OVC or MEAC school will make a lot of people happy. xcoffeex

[Edge316007]

Montana, regardless of what they do against MSU, are likely in.

[whitey]

IN:

James Madison - AQ
Appalachian State - AQ
Weber State - AQ
South Carolina State - AQ
New Hampshire - At Large
Wofford - At Large

[art vandelay]

UNH at 9-2, likely in.

no likely about it. there in

[CharlestonAppFan]

Which sucks. There are not 16 better teams than Maine in the nation. Don't worry though. I'm sure that 60-10 App win over an OVC or MEAC school will make a lot of people happy. xcoffeex

I wasn't trying to be negative, just posted that because it was likely a playoff game that didn't come out in your favor. BTW, I agree with you, but that's what we get with the autobids....sorry.

[whitey]

James Madison - AQ
Appalachian State - AQ
Weber State - AQ
South Carolina State - AQ
New Hampshire - At Large
Wofford - At Large
Richmond - At Large

[gabe01]

I started this thread to post teams that lock themselves in or eliminate themselves from the playoffs based on today's results or already have wrapped up the AQ...

AQ or likely At Large....

POST TEAMS as they occur.....

IN:

James Madison - AQ
Appalachian State - AQ
Weber State - AQ
South Carolina State - AQ

IN
Richmond
New Hampshire

OUT:
Maine
William & Mary
Furman

Elon out if they lose to Librty

[rcny46]

UNH at 9-2, likely in.


No doubt about it.

[appstate1998]

Dayton out lol

[dgreco]

Dayton out lol

xlolx xlolx rep

[alexale23]

IN
Richmond
New Hampshire

OUT:
Maine
William & Mary
Furman

Elon out if they lose to Librty

william and mary is not out if elon loses it will be between WM and liberty

[Edge316007]

^ Wouldn't Maine at 8-4 have a better case than W&M?

[whitey]

I dunno, Maine wouldn't have a win against anyone in the playoff field. W&M would since they beat New Hampshire.

[19Duke97]

^ Wouldn't Maine at 8-4 have a better case than W&M?

W&M beat UNH at UNH homecoming... so I think W&M gets the edge there.

[appstate1998]

^ Wouldn't Maine at 8-4 have a better case than W&M?

why? W&M has same conference record and they beat UNH

[Dukie95]

Villanova's in.

[appstate1998]

Villanova's in.

agreed

[JMU-MRD-DAD]

I see JMU, NOVA, UR and UNH in from the CAA period.....

[wocorebel]

Do you guys think the Committee would reward JMU with a soft SOCON team since App State is the only good team according to your coach by sending Wofford there in the first round?

[danefan]

Man this is going to be interesting.

[Reign of Terrier]

Do you guys think the Committee would reward JMU with a soft SOCON team since App State is the only good team according to your coach by sending Wofford there in the first round?

I doubt it.

[WoffDoc04]

Do you guys think the Committee would reward JMU with a soft SOCON team since App State is the only good team according to your coach by sending Wofford there in the first round?

Can we just go to Montana again instead?

[wocorebel]

I would rather play JMU if we have to travel because I could get there quicker than I could get to Orangeburg if they are making us travel. But, I would love a rematch at Gibbs against Richmond.

[bostonspider]

I'd rather the rematch be at UR stadium, it only seems fair at all...

[art vandelay]

W&M allways beats UNH perhaps the comitee will consiter that.

[danefan]

Colgate in.

[charliej]

I see JMU, NOVA, UR and UNH in from the CAA period.....

Agreed

[rcny46]

I see JMU, NOVA, UR and UNH in from the CAA period.....

I agree.

[ATrain]

Elon loses, they're out.

[danefan]

EKU is in with the OVC AQ.

[danefan]

James Madison - AQ
Appalachian State - AQ
Weber State - AQ
South Carolina State - AQ
EKU - AQ
Colgate - AQ
New Hampshire - At Large
Wofford - At Large
Richmond - At Large

[danefan]

Can we chalk Montana and Cal Poly in as At-larges?

[blur2005]

Can we chalk Montana and Cal Poly in as At-larges?
If Poly keeps it up against Wisconsin, they could be in the seed discussion, though I think Montana will grab one because Weber is going down hard against Eastern Washington...though I would somewhat disagree with this if it happened.

[Cocky]

Cal Poly in
EKU in

[danefan]

James Madison - AQ
Appalachian State - AQ
Weber State - AQ
South Carolina State - AQ
EKU - AQ
Colgate - AQ
New Hampshire - At Large
Wofford - At Large
Richmond - At Large
Cal Poly - At Large
Montana - At Large

[appstate1998]

If Poly keeps it up against Wisconsin, they could be in the seed discussion, though I think Montana will grab one because Weber is going down hard against Eastern Washington...though I would somewhat disagree with this if it happened.

If App loses and Weber loses I could see Montana, Cal Poly and UNH all getting seeds

[EKUSteve]

Does Liberty get in with their win over Elon?

[Dukie95]

If App loses and Weber loses I could see Montana, Cal Poly and UNH all getting seeds

Nova gets that CAA seed before UNH.

[danefan]

Does Liberty get in with their win over Elon?

Tough call, but Lafayette's loss to Lehigh hurts Liberty. They now have what looks like one really really really bad loss, one bad loss and only one good win.

[danefan]

James Madison - AQ
Appalachian State - AQ
Weber State - AQ
South Carolina State - AQ
EKU - AQ
Colgate - AQ
________ - SLC AQ
SIU/UNI - AQ
SIU/UNI - At-large
New Hampshire - At Large
Wofford - At Large
Richmond - At Large
Cal Poly - At Large
Montana - At Large
Villanova - At Large
_______ - At Large

[UNH Fanboi]

Tough call, but Lafayette's loss to Lehigh hurts Liberty. They now have what looks like one really really really bad loss, one bad loss and only one good win.

There's a glimmer of hope them because the committee may be hesitant to put 5 CAA teams in the playoffs for a second year in a row. But yeah, that loss to Presbyterian is terrible. If that had just won that game they'd probably be shoe-ins at this point.

[LUFan]

There's a glimmer of hope them because the committee may be hesitant to put 5 CAA teams in the playoffs for a second year in a row. But yeah, that loss to Presbyterian is terrible. If that had just won that game they'd probably be shoe-ins at this point.

As much as I would like to see us make the playoffs - I can't be upset if we don't after the Pres. game. No excuse for that

[tribe_pride]

For the last spot, looks like we have: (tell me if I missed someone, I think this is it and only Liberty (and maybe NDSU) of this group got it done today)

Liberty - 10-2 (8-2 in D-I games - 1 horrible loss, 1 not great loss - Best win over Elon - 3 game win streak to end)

WM - 7-4 (3 losses playoff teams and 1 to an FBS team - Best win over a playoff team - UNH - end with 2 straight losses after 5 game win streak)

Maine 8-4 (3 losses playoff teams and 1 to an FBS team - Best win UMass - end with a loss after 6 game win streak)

Elon 8-4 (3 losses to playoff teams and Liberty (potential playoff team), Best win - Furman - end with a loss and lose 3 of last 4)

NDSU 7-4 (if they win) - 1 loss to playoff team, 1 loss to FBS, 1 ok loss, 1 horrible loss, Best win playoff team SIU - end with a 4 game win streak)

[wocorebel]

I'd rather the rematch be at UR stadium, it only seems fair at all...

Nah, I think we should get a chance to avenge the home lose, and we are the more deserving team for a home game if we are matched.

[JALMOND]

It has been official since week 2, Portland State is out.xnodx

[bobcatfan06]

Texas State wins AQ for SLC.

[th0m]

W&M always beats UNH perhaps the committee will consider that.

How does that diminish their win? What if one team were to be undefeated for a couple of years.....do they just not get into the playoffs after a while? Because they "always beat all the teams they play" xlolx

Sorry, not trying to take your post out of context but just wondering what you meant by it more specifically.

[danefan]

James Madison - AQ
Appalachian State - AQ
Weber State - AQ
South Carolina State - AQ
EKU - AQ
Colgate - AQ
Texas State - AQ
SIU - AQ
UNI - At-large
New Hampshire - At Large
Wofford - At Large
Richmond - At Large
Cal Poly - At Large
Montana - At Large
Villanova - At Large
_______ - At Large

[knucklehead]

As much as I would like to see us make the playoffs - I can't be upset if we don't after the Pres. game. No excuse for that


If that loss proves to be the committe's reason for keeping LU out, it would be hard to argue that!

[BigSouthFB]

Last year the committee allowed a Montana St. team into the playoffs with a DII loss. That loss was worse than losing to a FCS team that is about to be in the conference. I agree it is a bad loss but I think the committee will be forgiving of one bad loss for liberty.

[danefan]

Last year the committee allowed a Montana St. team into the playoffs with a DII loss. That loss was worse than losing to a FCS team that is about to be in the conference. I agree it is a bad loss but I think the committee will be forgiving of one bad loss for liberty.

That was two years ago and MSU also had an FBS win at Colorado. Liberty can claim no similar win.

[JMUNJ08]

Liberty would be very easy for the committee to match up with the JMU...

[BobcatTXST04]

James Madison - AQ
Appalachian State - AQ
Weber State - AQ
South Carolina State - AQ
EKU - AQ
Colgate - AQ
Texas State - AQ
SIU - AQ
UNI - At-large
New Hampshire - At Large
Wofford - At Large
Richmond - At Large
Cal Poly - At Large
Montana - At Large
Villanova - At Large
_______ - At Large

That sounds so good! Let's hope we can represent the SLC well and have a long, deep playoff run!