Which Goalie Should Be First Team?

[UNHWildCats]

Player A

Junior played 1,494 minutes allowing 44 goals and a 1.77 Goal against average while finishing with a 12-11-2 record.


Player B

Freshman played 1,784 minutes allowing 31 goals and a 1.04 GAA while recording a record of 26-2-1.

Which of these two players should have been voted First Team All Conference?

[Peems]

Player A xnodx

[UNHWildCats]

Player A xnodx

Any particular reason?

[FCS_pwns_FBS]

Something stinking in the world of CAA soccer?

[UNHWildCats]

nah just Women's Hockey East.

[tribe_pride]

Player A

Junior played 1,494 minutes allowing 44 goals and a 1.77 Goal against average while finishing with a 12-11-2 record.


Player B

Freshman played 1,784 minutes allowing 31 goals and a 1.04 GAA while recording a record of 26-2-1.

Which of these two players should have been voted First Team All Conference?

Amt of Saves (Save %), Quality of Competition (or are these just conference stats), quality of own team (ability to clear out rebounds, ability to make sure shots can be seen by goalie and shoot from the outside)?

[TheValleyRaider]

Player B also faced nearly double the shots and had a much less talented team in front of her xwhistlex

[UNHWildCats]

Amt of Saves (Save %), Quality of Competition (or are these just conference stats), quality of own team (ability to clear out rebounds, ability to make sure shots can be seen by goalie and shoot from the outside)?


Player B also faced nearly double the shots and had a much less talented team in front of her xwhistlex


Player A had 613 saves and a .925 save percent.

Player B had 500 saves and a .942 save percent.

[UNHWildCats]

the stats and records are from the whole season not just conference play

[Cleets]

Player A xnodx

And you call me a smart ass ... xlolx

[UNHWildCats]

just in conference

Player A

32 Goals against for a 1.76 GAA in 1092 minutes and a 9-8-1 record

Player B

15 goals against for a 0.83 GAA in 1087 minutes and a 17-0-1 record

[otto4pres]

Player A is prettier