PDA

View Full Version : AGS Playoff Bracket Challenge - After Quarterfinals, Fall 2021



Preferred Walk-On
December 12th, 2021, 11:27 AM
3rd round (quarterfinals)...over. We'll have a new FCS champion this year, and we should have some great fluctuations in the standings in the coming two weeks, given that a significant portion of the leaders have lost one or both of their finalists. However, here (see below) is where we sit after the quarterfinals (and remember, you can always check out the standings, brackets, pick distribution, score/margin differentials, etc by clicking on the link in my signature).

Notables this week were Professor Chaos leading the points scored in the quarterfinal round, El Cid leading in the number of correct picks, and caribbeanhen still leads the overall score; however, Sam Houston losing has put a little crimp in that going forward. As for predicting scores and margins of victory, caribbeanhen led the way in predicting the game scores, and Professor Chaos led in predicting score margins. It is not surprising that these are your current game leaders.



Player
Quarterfinals
Total
# Correct


caribbeanhen
114
360
16


Professor Chaos
129
355
16


putter
111
353
17


ElCid
105
351
18


Pitz
102
336
16


ST_Lawson
99
323
16


Chalupa Batman
102
322
16


dewey
96
322
17


OhioHen
75
322
17


Catbooster
120
320
16


Karl Havoc
96
316
15


FCSbuff319
78
315
16


MSUWineGuy
111
313
15


HensRock
87
308
16


RabidRabbit
99
308
14


taper
72
303
16


Carolina010
72
302
15


NOLA
102
302
14


MSUBobcat
69
301
15


Prime Power
96
300
16


wapiti
90
299
15


Roamingriz
72
298
15


Katfan
93
297
16


Preferred Walk-On
78
296
15


THE DANIMAL
78
292
14


Go Lehigh TU owl
72
291
14


Bisonator
93
290
15


MR. CHICKEN
69
290
15


TheValleyRaider
63
289
15


POD Knows
99
288
15


Griz23
66
286
14


atthewbon
63
285
16


JacksFan40
75
285
14


mvfcfan
63
285
15


BigBlueMU
63
284
14


footballer23
81
284
13


CockyGeek
60
283
15


Hambone
60
282
15


MSUDuo
90
282
14


bobcathpdevil56
93
281
14


ming01
78
279
11


mvemjsunpx
69
279
13


GoBlueHens83
75
278
13


crusader11
60
273
15


JSUSoutherner
63
259
13


MTfan4life
72
254
12


HootyHoo
39
246
13


grizband
42
232
12


katss07
36
230
13


KsawOwls
18
230
12


Daytripper
42
222
12


paward
15
217
12


bonarae
30
203
12


Libertine
42
197
10


Puddin Tane
27
160
10


CenMEBlackBearFan

75
6


Mfergy4

74
6


Anthony215

45
4


bob12

0
0


dgtw

0
0


Drblankstare

0
0


Gangtackle11

0
0


McNeese75

0
0


NY Crusader 2010

0
0


PantherRob82

0
0


SpreadTheWord

0
0


TheKingpin28

0
0

Professor Chaos
December 12th, 2021, 11:38 AM
Really wish I would've just gone with the same picks I made here in MTfan4life's pick 'em game instead of re-thinking things. Clearly I was much smarter 3 weeks ago than I was last week. :)

caribbeanhen
December 12th, 2021, 04:44 PM
Thanks for the shout out Full Ride

I forgot I picked Sammy to win it all and how could I ... that was dumb

nice while it lasted

ST_Lawson
December 12th, 2021, 09:58 PM
If I remember correctly, I think I picked a All Dakota State final with the Bison winning a close one, so I've still got a chance at some more points.

Professor Chaos
December 12th, 2021, 10:11 PM
If I remember correctly, I think I picked a All Dakota State final with the Bison winning a close one, so I've still got a chance at some more points.
I've got NDSU over Montana St in the final so you'll pick up a bunch of points on me if SDSU wins.

Preferred Walk-On
December 13th, 2021, 07:57 AM
If I remember correctly, I think I picked a All Dakota State final with the Bison winning a close one, so I've still got a chance at some more points.

All the picks and all players' brackets are accessible in the link in my signature. Also, your original bracket link should work (but winning and losing teams are not denoted there).

Below is a summary of players that have one or both semifinalists left (clustered by matchup and sorted by total points thus far from highest-to-lowest):



Both Semifinalists and National Champion Still Alive






Player
Total Points
Semifinalist 1
Semifinalist 2
Champion


South Dakota State v. North Dakota State






ST_Lawson
323
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


dewey
322
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


MSUWineGuy
313
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


HensRock
308
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


taper
303
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Carolina010
302
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
South Dakota State


Prime Power
300
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Preferred Walk-On
296
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Bisonator
290
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Griz23
286
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


atthewbon
285
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
South Dakota State


JacksFan40
285
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
South Dakota State


JSUSoutherner
259
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Montana State v. North Dakota State






Professor Chaos
355
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Catbooster
320
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


MSUBobcat
301
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


wapiti
299
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


footballer23
284
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


bobcathpdevil56
281
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


South Dakota State v. James Madison






Karl Havoc
316
South Dakota State
James Madison
James Madison


One Semifinalist and National Champion Still Alive






Chalupa Batman
322
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


OhioHen
322
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


NOLA
302
South Dakota State
Eastern Washington
South Dakota State


Roamingriz
298
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Go Lehigh TU owl
291
Missouri State
James Madison
James Madison


TheValleyRaider
289
Villanova
James Madison
James Madison


mvfcfan
285
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


ming01
279
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


crusader11
273
Sam Houston
James Madison
James Madison


MTfan4life
254
Villanova
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


grizband
232
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State

POD Knows
December 13th, 2021, 08:51 AM
All the picks and all players' brackets are accessible in the link in my signature. Also, your original bracket link should work (but winning and losing teams are not denoted there).

Below is a summary of players that have one or both semifinalists left (clustered by matchup and sorted by total points thus far from highest-to-lowest):



Both Semifinalists and National Champion Still Alive






Player
Total Points
Semifinalist 1
Semifinalist 2
Champion


South Dakota State v. North Dakota State






ST_Lawson
323
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


dewey
322
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


MSUWineGuy
313
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


HensRock
308
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


taper
303
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Carolina010
302
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
South Dakota State


Prime Power
300
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Preferred Walk-On
296
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Bisonator
290
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Griz23
286
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


atthewbon
285
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
South Dakota State


JacksFan40
285
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
South Dakota State


JSUSoutherner
259
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Montana State v. North Dakota State






Professor Chaos
355
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Catbooster
320
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


MSUBobcat
301
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


wapiti
299
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


footballer23
284
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


bobcathpdevil56
281
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


South Dakota State v. James Madison






Karl Havoc
316
South Dakota State
James Madison
James Madison


One Semifinalist and National Champion Still Alive






Chalupa Batman
322
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


OhioHen
322
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


NOLA
302
South Dakota State
Eastern Washington
South Dakota State


Roamingriz
298
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Go Lehigh TU owl
291
Missouri State
James Madison
James Madison


TheValleyRaider
289
Villanova
James Madison
James Madison


mvfcfan
285
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


ming01
279
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


crusader11
273
Sam Houston
James Madison
James Madison


MTfan4life
254
Villanova
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


grizband
232
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State



I had JMU and SHSU in the finals. What am I missing here. Also. For some odd reason. I cannot access the link in your sig line but I am sure that is a problem on my end

Professor Chaos
December 13th, 2021, 09:11 AM
All the picks and all players' brackets are accessible in the link in my signature. Also, your original bracket link should work (but winning and losing teams are not denoted there).

Below is a summary of players that have one or both semifinalists left (clustered by matchup and sorted by total points thus far from highest-to-lowest):



Both Semifinalists and National Champion Still Alive






Player
Total Points
Semifinalist 1
Semifinalist 2
Champion


South Dakota State v. North Dakota State






ST_Lawson
323
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


dewey
322
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


MSUWineGuy
313
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


HensRock
308
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


taper
303
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Carolina010
302
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
South Dakota State


Prime Power
300
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Preferred Walk-On
296
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Bisonator
290
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Griz23
286
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


atthewbon
285
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
South Dakota State


JacksFan40
285
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
South Dakota State


JSUSoutherner
259
South Dakota State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Montana State v. North Dakota State






Professor Chaos
355
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Catbooster
320
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


MSUBobcat
301
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


wapiti
299
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


footballer23
284
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


bobcathpdevil56
281
Montana State
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


South Dakota State v. James Madison






Karl Havoc
316
South Dakota State
James Madison
James Madison


One Semifinalist and National Champion Still Alive






Chalupa Batman
322
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


OhioHen
322
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


NOLA
302
South Dakota State
Eastern Washington
South Dakota State


Roamingriz
298
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


Go Lehigh TU owl
291
Missouri State
James Madison
James Madison


TheValleyRaider
289
Villanova
James Madison
James Madison


mvfcfan
285
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


ming01
279
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


crusader11
273
Sam Houston
James Madison
James Madison


MTfan4life
254
Villanova
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


grizband
232
Sam Houston
North Dakota State
North Dakota State


After seeing this all I want to say is "Go Bobcats!"

Preferred Walk-On
December 13th, 2021, 09:22 AM
I had JMU and SHSU in the finals. What am I missing here. Also. For some odd reason. I cannot access the link in your sig line but I am sure that is a problem on my end

Hey POD, you are exactly correct (JMU and SH in the finals). What is missing is that you picked the Bearkats to win it. I only posted those that had one or both semifinalists AND a champion still available. As for the link in my signature, I am not sure why it is not accessible. I tried it not logged in to AGS or any Google accounts, and it worked for me. Sorry I cannot be of much assistance on that front.

Preferred Walk-On
December 13th, 2021, 09:25 AM
After seeing this all I want to say is "Go Bobcats!"

I am enjoying the fact that it is really a win-win for me on the SDSU @ MSU game. It will be fun just watching and enjoying that game. I am curious to see which SDSU AND which MSU shows up.

caribbeanhen
December 13th, 2021, 09:27 AM
I would laugh at POD for picking Sammy to win it but I did the same stupid thing and will now crash and burn

anyway with all the book it’s nobody knows who POD is really picking

Preferred Walk-On
December 13th, 2021, 09:33 AM
I would laugh at POD for picking Sammy to win it but I did the same stupid thing and will now crash and burn

anyway with all the book it’s nobody knows who POD is really picking

Brilliant strategy. #BOOKIT power to help eliminate SH and JMU, but if they win, an "I told ya' so." is right around the corner. He is a genius.

POD Knows
December 13th, 2021, 09:36 AM
Brilliant strategy. #BOOKIT power to help eliminate SH and JMU, but if they win, an "I told ya' so." is right around the corner. He is a genius.
I have never said I told you so on any pick I have ever made. You have to get picks correct in order to do that.

POD Knows
December 13th, 2021, 09:37 AM
Hey POD, you are exactly correct (JMU and SH in the finals). What is missing is that you picked the Bearkats to win it. I only posted those that had one or both semifinalists AND a champion still available. As for the link in my signature, I am not sure why it is not accessible. I tried it not logged in to AGS or any Google accounts, and it worked for me. Sorry I cannot be of much assistance on that front.
It is my iPhone. I have issues with Google docs. Onward and upward.

Preferred Walk-On
December 13th, 2021, 09:39 AM
I have never said I told you so on any pick I have ever made. You have to get picks correct in order to do that.

Modest. Even better.

- - - Updated - - -


It is my iPhone. I have issues with Google docs. Onward and upward.

Yeah, only opens on my iPhone through the Google Sheets app, and even that is not optimal.

caribbeanhen
December 13th, 2021, 05:12 PM
Is Massey playing in this game?

POD Knows
December 13th, 2021, 06:26 PM
Modest. Even better.

- - - Updated - - -



Yeah, only opens on my iPhone through the Google Sheets app, and even that is not optimal.
I am the most modest person that ever lived. Is it modest to state that. Anyway **** SDSU.

NY Crusader 2010
December 15th, 2021, 08:09 PM
I'm a little bummed out. I know I submitted my picks for the quarters, semis and finals. Not sure what happened. Pretty sure I had all 4 quarters correct too, as I predicted Montana to beat Sam.

Preferred Walk-On
December 16th, 2021, 08:50 AM
I'm a little bummed out. I know I submitted my picks for the quarters, semis and finals. Not sure what happened. Pretty sure I had all 4 quarters correct too, as I predicted Montana to beat Sam.

Sorry to hear that. According to Google, no picks were ever submitted (so you would have seen this on the previous two weeks I have posted updates about the challenge), and even looking back through the entire document's history, there were no edits. Not sure what else to tell you.

caribbeanhen
December 16th, 2021, 08:53 AM
Is Massey playing in this game?

I guess not

Just curious to see how the computer stacks up

Preferred Walk-On
December 16th, 2021, 09:03 AM
I guess not

Just curious to see how the computer stacks up

If somebody gets me the Massey predictions for the previous rounds, I can enter them into a bracket and we could see what it looks like.

caribbeanhen
December 16th, 2021, 09:07 AM
If somebody gets me the Massey predictions for the previous rounds, I can enter them into a bracket and we could see what it looks like.

I knew this was coming

busted

Karl Havoc
December 16th, 2021, 09:54 AM
Surprised to see I’m the only one with a JMU/SDSU final! Looks like I’m still alive in the contest.

Preferred Walk-On
December 16th, 2021, 10:21 AM
Surprised to see I’m the only one with a JMU/SDSU final! Looks like I’m still alive in the contest.

You are absolutely alive. However, and this is not personal at all, I am hoping you that are not alive in the contest after Friday evening. ;)

Preferred Walk-On
December 16th, 2021, 10:28 AM
I knew this was coming

busted

It was predictable. ;)

I think there could be a problem with the Massey comparison, however. The Massey predictions would be more suitable for MTfan4life's contest, as his goes week-by-week. I don't think Massey predicted the entire bracket, just week-by-week, and that data is adjusted weekly as well, right? We could do the comparison substituting in predicted scores and assuming those scores carry over to a matchup where a team is no longer playing (just like we are doing for all the brackets), but Massey gets to enter scores after the actual matchup is set, not before like everyone else did.

NY Crusader 2010
December 17th, 2021, 12:29 PM
Sorry to hear that. According to Google, no picks were ever submitted (so you would have seen this on the previous two weeks I have posted updates about the challenge), and even looking back through the entire document's history, there were no edits. Not sure what else to tell you.

See you next year

ElCid
December 17th, 2021, 03:47 PM
If somebody gets me the Massey predictions for the previous rounds, I can enter them into a bracket and we could see what it looks like.

I have them all. I'll PM you later.

***in your in box now.

Preferred Walk-On
December 18th, 2021, 10:53 AM
I have them all. I'll PM you later.

***in your in box now.

I have generated a Massey bracket in the score sheet in my signature. This bracket is based off of the weekly Massey predictions, and the championship game was done using the matchup predictor. Next year, I'll have to remember to use the predictor before all the playoff games start to get a better representation of the Massey bracket. I am curious if Sam Houston had won last week, what the South Dakota State @ Sam Houston matchup would have looked like to Massey. Would Massey still have predicted a Jackrabbit win? Anywho, Massey is now in the Challenge retroactively. Enjoy!

caribbeanhen
December 19th, 2021, 08:37 AM
Thank you for doing the Massey bracket with a Big assist to El Cid

Seems like everybody likes to criticize Massey but ole Dexter Massey Riley is definitely holding his own and always does.